Incident record · Initial review 14 March 2024 · Closed to immediate response
Scope
This record concerns a discrepancy found in digital copies of patient administration registers from an unnamed regional hospital. It does not establish that a patient existed without an admission, nor that the source records were altered.
Circumstances
On 14 March 2024, a records auditor attempting to reconcile historical patient identifiers noticed that the supplied discharge index contained one unpaired discharge entry per completed reporting day in the relevant historical dataset. The pattern appeared to extend back to 1979.
An “unpaired” entry in this context is a discharge transaction without a matching admission identifier in the exported index. It does not mean that the total number of discharges must exceed total daily admissions. Staff census and patient stays across reporting periods make those totals different even under routine conditions.
The auditor escalated the issue after finding the same pattern in an image set described as copies of handwritten patient registers.
Chronology
| Date | Recorded event | Evidentiary limit |
|---|---|---|
| 2024-03-14 | The discharge-index discrepancy was identified. | Dataset origin and export settings were not independently reproduced. |
| 2024-03-18 | Investigators received six photographic bundles of historical register pages. | Chain of copying was incomplete. |
| 2024-04-23 | Interviews with former staff continued after initial procedural explanations were deemed inadequate. | Questions and sequence of interviews were not consistently preserved. |
| 2024-05-02 | New identity-matching interviews were paused. | Reported interview-team memory inconsistencies were not independently measured. |
| 2026-05-06 | Later inspection of original bound registers did not reproduce the extra daily entry. | See the superseding review memorandum. |
Immediate handling
The reviewing office retained its copies, requested access to the original registers, and instructed personnel to record separately what they saw in a source and what they inferred about missing patients.
No restrictions were imposed on the hospital’s ordinary patient care.
Finding
Observed: A specific supplied dataset and copy collection displayed a repeating unpaired-entry pattern.
Unresolved: Whether the pattern originated in the hospital’s records, in a transformation of those records, or in the institution’s own processing.
Disputed: The early working conclusion that a historically present unidentified patient caused the discrepancy.
Linked material
- Evidence EVD-2024-001 describes the supplied register copies.
- Personal account ACC-2024-001 preserves one witness’s perspective.
- Investigation INV-2026-001 reviews the incident after the 2026 audit.
Editorial note: This is wholly fictional, non-canon design material.

