Review memorandum · 6 May 2026 · Revised 21 November 2026
Claim under review
The initial investigation held that the discharge discrepancy appeared in the hospital’s handwritten original registers and that staff recollections independently supported the existence of a recurring unidentified patient.
This memorandum reviews the evidentiary basis for that statement. The original claim remains part of the investigation’s history but is not retained as an established finding.
Review methods
A separate team examined the original volumes at the hospital without access to the previous investigators’ annotated image bundles. The team reconstructed the selected pages’ chronological order and compared daily entries with the delivered digital photographs.
No matching unpaired entries were identified in the original pages examined.
The review also compared available interview questions with later summaries. Several prompts introduced details of an “extra patient” before witnesses supplied those details themselves.
Findings
| Claim | Disposition | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Copies exhibit a repeated reconciliation discrepancy. | Observed | Original delivered files preserved in accession storage. |
| Original handwritten volumes exhibit that same discrepancy. | Withdrawn | Independent comparison did not reproduce it. |
| Seven former staff independently remembered a specific extra patient. | Disputed | Interview prompts may have influenced descriptions; independent corroboration was not established. |
| Investigators experienced memory discrepancies after interviews. | Reported | Written statements exist, but no independent assessment of the alleged effects has been completed. |
Disagreement
Two members of the original team dispute the review’s conclusion and maintain that the bound volumes appeared different during their first inspection.
The review does not accept this assertion as a finding. It also does not treat the disagreement itself as evidence of a supernatural alteration.
Decision
The source-original conclusion is withdrawn. The investigation remains open because the divergence between delivered copies and original volumes is not yet explained.
No claim has been established about the existence, identity, or nature of an additional patient.
Consequence for procedure
Further witness identity-matching interviews remain suspended pending an independent methodology review. See ASM-2026-001.
Linked material
- EVD-2024-001 provides the evidence provenance.
- ACC-2024-001 illustrates interviewer-introduced detail.
- INV-2026-001 incorporates this review without erasing the earlier conclusion.
Editorial note: Fictional specimen; not published canon.

